What better way to get into the holiday spirit than with a grumpy/sunshine romance featuring a hockey player, a physical therapist, and a fake engagement? Fake It Under the Mistletoe is the third book in the Faking the Holidays series. This installment introduces us to Montserrat Hartley and Crew Wolfcraft.
Title: Fake It Under the Mistletoe A Fake Engagement Hockey Christmas Romance
Author(s): Claudia Y. Burgoa
Series: Faking the Holidays #3
Also in this series: Fake it 'Til Christmas: A Grumpy Sunshine Romance
Narrator(s): Jason Clarke, Stacy Gonzalez
Published by Self-published on November 4, 2026 hours
Pages: 310
Length: 7 hours 21 minutes
Genre(s): Contemporary Romance
Source: Author
Format: ALC, ARC

Purchase: Amazon|Audible
Series Rating:



Heat Level:

There are three things people should know before letting me near an injured professional athlete.
One, I am very good at my job.
Two, my bedside manner has been described as "aggressively cheerful in a way that feels humanly questionable."
Three, I will absolutely threaten a grown man with resistance bands if he lies to me about his pain level.Crew Wolfcraft lies about his pain level. Constantly.
He also has a hip that's one bad twist from ending his career, a charity weekend he'd rather die than attend, and the conversational range of a man being held hostage. I've been hired to keep him upright through Christmas. That's the job.
Then a reporter asks a question under the mistletoe, Crew opens his mouth, and my grandmother's ring—the one on my hand, the one being resized, the one I am absolutely not engaged with—becomes a headline.
I don't correct him.
In my defense: my Tía Marta has lined up a dentist, an architect, and a firefighter for me to meet before Christmas Eve.
Now there's a tamalada, four aunts with a group chat and no fear of God, a cat named Don Gato Corleone who has chosen him over me, and a man who was supposed to leave in January learning my grandmother's recipes like he's planning to stay.I can rehab a hip in eight weeks.
I have no idea what to do about the rest.
I received this book for free in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
Montserrat is assigned to help Crew recover from a career-threatening injury. However, a misunderstanding involving her grandmother’s ring leads the two into an unexpected fake engagement. Now they must navigate family expectations, public perceptions, and holiday celebrations while pretending to be in love. But as they spend more time together, their fake arrangement gradually develops into something genuine.
Montserrat and Crew had some entertaining interactions, and I enjoyed the humor and witty banter between them. Her confidence and playful personality provide the perfect complement to Crew’s stubborn, grumpy nature. I liked watching them slowly let their guards down as their connection grew. Beneath all the humor, both had their own insecurities and vulnerabilities to overcome. As they got closer, they began opening up to each other. They learn to trust each other while realizing that perhaps they wanted more than their fake arrangement.
I particularly enjoyed Montserrat’s lively family. They welcomed Crew with open arms, and their interactions added warmth to the story. There is something special about a family that makes you feel right at home, and they certainly brought that festive family atmosphere.
Listening to the audiobook while following along with the e-book made for a fun reading experience. Jason Clarke and Stacy Gonzalez were fantastic as Crew and Montserrat. Their chemistry and witty banter came through naturally, and they did a great job bringing the characters’ personalities to life. Stacy’s Spanish accent was a lovely touch that added authenticity to Montserrat’s dialogue and further brought her character to life.
While I enjoyed the chemistry and humorous exchanges between the main characters, the romance was a slow burn, and the pacing was slower than I would have liked. At times, the story took a little too long to move forward, which affected my overall enjoyment.
Overall, Fake It Under the Mistletoe delivered a charming holiday romance with a grumpy hockey player, a confident physical therapist, plenty of witty banter, and a fake engagement that turned into something more. Although the pacing didn’t always work for me, Montserrat and Crew’s journey had its enjoyable moments. It’s a sweet addition to the series and a nice choice for readers looking for a little holiday romance.
| Story Evaluation | |
|---|---|
| Plot | |
| Characters | |
| World Building | |
| Writing Style | |
| Pacing | |
| Cover | |
| Narrator (Audio) | |
| Enjoyment | |
| Ending | |
| Overall: | ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |








